Category Archives: sixth circuit court

>Right-Wing Blogosphere Downplays Conservative Judge’s Opinion Upholding Health Care Reform Law

>

If government can mandate auto insurance, homeowners insurance, flood insurance….Then it only makes sense that government can mandate health insurance. I believe that the Sixth Circuit Court and Judge Jeffery Sutton got it right.

From MediaMatters.org
July 01, 2011

After the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld the constitutionality of the individual mandate provision of the Affordable Care Act, many right-wing bloggers criticized the decision or downplayed its significance. But one of the judges who voted to uphold the statute was Jeffrey Sutton, an appointee of President George W. Bush who was such a proponent of states’ rights during his legal career that he once proclaimed that he became involved in states’ rights issues because “I really believe in this federalism stuff.”

By A 2-1 Vote, The Sixth Circuit Upholds The Constitutionality Of The Individual Mandate. In Thomas More Law Center v. Obama, the Sixth Circuit held by a vote of 2 to 1 that the provision of the Affordable Care Act mandating that individuals purchase health insurance does not violate the Constitution. The majority consisted of Sixth Circuit judges Boyce Martin and Jeffrey Sutton. District Judge James Graham, acting as a Sixth Circuit judge in this case, dissented. [Thomas More Law Center v. Obama, 6/29/11]


Read more HERE

Leave a comment

Filed under health care reform, Judge Jeffery Sutton, Media Matters, President George W. Bush, Right-wing bloggers, sixth circuit court, The Affordable Care Act, Thomas More Law Center v. Obama